.jpg)
After years of working with clients who seemed to make progress only to plateau or relapse, I began to notice a pattern. The clients whose changes lasted had usually done more than change their behaviours. They had connected the eating disorder to their own story.
The limitation of surface-level treatment:
Traditional eating disorder treatment often focuses on the "what" - what behaviours to change, what skills to learn, what meals to eat. These elements matter, but on their own they can miss the "why" behind the eating disorder.
When we only address symptoms without exploring their origins, we're asking clients to give up ways of coping that have served a purpose without fully understanding what that purpose was. It's like asking someone to throw away a life jacket without first teaching them to swim.
Behaviour-focused treatments such as CBT-E and FBT work well for some people. For others, something important is missing. Relapse after anorexia treatment is common, especially in the first year (Khalsa et al., 2017). For some clients, a turning point comes when they see the connection between their current struggles and their past experiences. That moment when they realise their perfectionism around food connects to growing up in a chaotic household. The insight that their body image struggles link to early messages about worth and appearance. The recognition that their eating disorder emerged as a way to cope with trauma or loss of control.
These connections can also build motivation for change.
Moving beyond "what happened" to "what it means":
Exploring eating disorder origins isn't about dwelling in the past or assigning blame. It's about helping clients understand the logic of their symptoms within the context of their life story. When clients can see how the eating disorder developed as an understandable response to difficult circumstances, shame often softens into self-compassion.
This understanding creates several powerful shifts:
A framework for exploring where the eating disorder came from:
Effective exploration of eating disorder origins involves examining four key areas:
Life experiences that shaped their worldview - particularly around food, body, safety, and worth. This includes family dynamics, cultural messages, traumatic events, and experiences of marginalisation or discrimination.
Core beliefs that developed as a result of these experiences - about themselves, others, and the world. These often unconscious beliefs become the lens through which they interpret new experiences.
Protective strategies they developed to cope with distressing beliefs and feelings. These adaptive responses made perfect sense in their original context, even if they've become problematic over time.
Current behaviours that stem from these earlier adaptations. When clients can trace their eating disorder behaviours back to their protective origins, they often feel less ashamed and more able to change.
Creating the conditions for deep work:
This level of exploration requires safety, trust, and the right timing. Clients need to feel secure in the therapeutic relationship and have adequate emotional resources before diving into deep work. Go at the client's pace and let them choose what to explore and when. There's no need to go looking for trauma.
The aim is to help clients see the sense in their survival strategies, without blaming anyone, while they build new ways to meet their needs.
Offer any link you notice as a possibility, and check it with the client. If they say it doesn't fit, believe them and let it go. The connections that matter most are the ones the client makes.
When clients connect with the deeper story behind their eating disorder, the work can start to feel like something they want, rather than something imposed on them.
In my experience, clients who do this work often notice changes beyond their eating, in relationships, self-esteem and sense of direction.
Supporting clients in this exploration:
A structured worksheet helps. The handout below gives clients a page to map four things: their life experiences, the beliefs that came from them, the ways they learned to protect themselves, and how those link to current eating disorder behaviours.
The most powerful tool is often the client's own wisdom. Our role is to provide the structure and safety for them to explore their story and make their own connections.
Using the handout with a client:
Work through it over several sessions, one area at a time. Start with life experiences, then beliefs, then protective strategies, and link these to current behaviours last. Let the client fill it in and make the links first. Add yours as questions, such as "I wonder if...", and keep working on the eating and behaviours alongside.
Download our free handout: Exploring the Maintenance & Development of Eating Disorders
Or see our alternative version for when the eating differences are mainly related to autism or ADHD
For training in this approach: Focal Psychodynamic Therapy (FPT) for Anorexia Nervosa
When clients understand why the eating disorder made sense, as well as what to change, the changes they make are more likely to feel like their own.
References
Khalsa, S. S., Portnoff, L. C., McCurdy-McKinnon, D., & Feusner, J. D. (2017). What happens after treatment? A systematic review of relapse, remission, and recovery in anorexia nervosa. Journal of Eating Disorders, 5, 20.
We do not offer a one size fits all but instead see each client as a whole person requiring an individualised approach.
View our servicesOur psychologists and dietitian are skilled in the areas of neurodivergence, eating disorders, & complex trauma.
Meet the teamOur approach is neurodiversity affirming, trauma-informed, weight neutral, and intersectional.
Book online